Back to Fixed Income

Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies

5 minutes 5 Questions

Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies are two pivotal approaches in fixed income portfolio management, particularly within the framework of Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Level 3. **Liability-Driven Strategies (LDS):** LDS focus on aligning investment portfolios with the specific liabilities or obligations of an institution, such as pension funds or insurance companies. The primary objective is to ensure that the assets' cash flows and duration match the timing and magnitude of the liabilities. This minimizes the risk of funding shortfalls. Key components include: 1. **Cash Flow Matching:** Selecting fixed income securities whose cash flows precisely meet future liabilities. 2. **Duration Matching:** Adjusting the portfolio's duration to align with the liability's duration, reducing interest rate risk. 3. **Immunization:** Structuring the portfolio so that its value is insensitive to interest rate movements, typically through matching duration and convexity. LDS prioritize risk management over returns, ensuring that the portfolio can meet its obligations under various economic scenarios. **Index-Based Strategies:** Index-based strategies aim to replicate or track the performance of a specific fixed income index, such as the Bloomberg Barclays Aggregate Bond Index. This passive management approach seeks to achieve returns comparable to the benchmark with lower costs and minimal active decision-making. Key aspects include: 1. **Passive Management:** Minimizing trading and maintaining a portfolio that mirrors the index composition. 2. **Diversification:** Achieving broad exposure to various sectors, issuers, and maturities as per the index. 3. **Cost Efficiency:** Lower management fees due to the passive nature of the strategy. These strategies are suitable for investors seeking market-average returns without the need for active management or specialized insight. They also provide a clear performance benchmark, facilitating performance measurement and attribution. **Comparison:** While LDS are tailored to specific liability profiles with a focus on risk management, index-based strategies prioritize market participation and cost efficiency. In practice, institutional investors may combine both approaches: using LDS to ensure liability coverage and employing index-based methods for excess asset management, striving to balance risk, return, and cost objectives.

Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies

Why it's important:
Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies are crucial for CFA Level 3 candidates to understand as they are commonly used by institutional investors to manage risk and achieve specific investment objectives. These strategies are frequently tested on the Fixed Income section of the exam.

What it is:
Liability-Driven Investing (LDI) is a strategy that focuses on managing assets to meet specific liabilities, typically used by pension funds and insurance companies. The goal is to minimize the risk of not having sufficient assets to cover future liabilities.

Index-Based Strategies involve constructing portfolios that track a specific bond market index, such as the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index. These strategies aim to match the performance of the index while minimizing tracking error.

How it works:
LDI strategies involve analyzing the liabilities and constructing a portfolio of fixed income securities with cash flows that match the timing and amount of the liabilities. This is done through a combination of duration matching, cash flow matching, and immunization techniques.

Index-Based Strategies are implemented by investing in a portfolio of bonds that closely resembles the composition of the target index. This can be done through full replication (holding all securities in the index) or stratified sampling (holding a representative subset of the index).

Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies
1. Understand the key concepts and terminology related to LDI and Index-Based Strategies, such as duration matching, cash flow matching, immunization, tracking error, and stratified sampling.
2. Be familiar with the main reasons for using these strategies and the types of investors who commonly employ them.
3. Practice calculating key metrics, such as duration, convexity, and tracking error.
4. When answering questions, carefully read the question stem and identify the specific strategy being discussed (LDI or Index-Based).
5. Focus on the main objectives and constraints of the investor mentioned in the question, as these will guide your answer.
6. Show your work when performing calculations, as partial credit may be awarded for correct steps even if the final answer is incorrect.

Test mode:
Start practice test
CFA Level 3 - Fixed Income Example Questions

Test your knowledge of Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3)

Question 1

You are a portfolio manager for a defined benefit pension plan with long-term liabilities. The plan's investment policy statement emphasizes the importance of minimizing funding ratio volatility while maintaining a sufficient level of expected return. The current asset allocation consists of 60% equities and 40% fixed income, with a duration gap of 3 years between the assets and liabilities. Given the recent market volatility and the plan sponsor's concerns about interest rate risk, you are considering implementing a liability-driven investment (LDI) strategy. Which of the following approaches would be most appropriate for the plan's objectives?

Correct Answer: Increase the allocation to fixed income securities with durations that closely match the liabilities, while maintaining a smaller allocation to equities for potential growth.

The most appropriate approach for the pension plan's objectives is to increase the allocation to fixed income securities with durations that closely match the liabilities, while maintaining a smaller allocation to equities for potential growth. This strategy, known as liability-driven investing (LDI), helps minimize funding ratio volatility by aligning the duration of the assets with the duration of the liabilities. By doing so, the plan's assets and liabilities will respond similarly to changes in interest rates, reducing the risk of underfunding. Maintaining a smaller allocation to equities provides the potential for higher returns, which can help improve the plan's funding status over the long term. Shifting the entire portfolio to fixed income securities would eliminate the potential for higher returns from equities, which could hinder the plan's ability to meet its long-term obligations. Using interest rate derivatives to hedge the duration gap can be an effective strategy, but it may introduce additional complexity and counterparty risk compared to directly adjusting the asset allocation.

Question 2

You are managing a defined benefit pension plan with $400 million in assets and liabilities that have a duration of 14 years. The current asset allocation is 70% equities and 30% fixed income, with a duration of 6 years for the fixed income portion. The investment committee has expressed concern about the plan's interest rate risk exposure and its impact on the funded status. They are also worried about the portfolio's concentration in equities, given the recent market volatility. As the portfolio manager, you are considering implementing a liability-driven investment (LDI) strategy to better align the assets with the liabilities and manage risk. Which of the following approaches would be most appropriate given the plan's objectives and current situation?

Correct Answer: Gradually increase the allocation to fixed income securities while extending the duration of the fixed income portfolio to better match the liabilities, and consider incorporating derivative instruments to manage interest rate risk and maintain some equity exposure for potential growth.

The most appropriate approach given the plan's objectives and current situation is to gradually increase the allocation to fixed income securities while extending the duration of the fixed income portfolio to better match the liabilities. This strategy, known as liability-driven investing (LDI), aims to align the assets with the liabilities to manage interest rate risk and reduce the volatility of the plan's funded status. By extending the duration of the fixed income portfolio, the sensitivity of the assets to interest rate changes will more closely match that of the liabilities, minimizing the impact of interest rate fluctuations on the funded status. Incorporating derivative instruments can further help manage interest rate risk and maintain some equity exposure for potential growth. Maintaining the current 70% equity allocation is not advisable, as it exposes the plan to significant market volatility and does not address the interest rate risk concern. While equities have historically outperformed fixed income over the long term, they do not provide a direct hedge against the plan's liabilities. Reducing the equity allocation to 50% and increasing the fixed income allocation to 50% without extending the duration of the fixed income portfolio does not adequately address the interest rate risk issue. The duration mismatch between the assets and liabilities would still persist, leaving the plan vulnerable to interest rate changes.

Question 3

You are a portfolio manager for a large insurance company with long-term liabilities. The company's current asset allocation is 60% fixed income and 40% equities, with a duration gap of 5 years between assets and liabilities. The investment policy statement emphasizes the importance of reducing interest rate risk while maintaining a well-diversified portfolio. Given the current low-yield environment and concerns about potential inflation, you are considering implementing a liability-driven investment (LDI) strategy along with an index-based approach to enhance returns and manage risk. Which of the following strategies would be most appropriate for the insurance company's objectives?

Correct Answer: Increase the allocation to long-duration fixed income securities to better match the liabilities, while using index-based strategies for the equity portion to maintain diversification and manage risk.

The most appropriate strategy for the insurance company's objectives is to increase the allocation to long-duration fixed income securities to better match the liabilities, while using index-based strategies for the equity portion to maintain diversification and manage risk. This strategy aligns with the company's goal of reducing interest rate risk by narrowing the duration gap between assets and liabilities through the use of long-duration fixed income securities. By matching the duration of assets more closely to the long-term liabilities, the company can mitigate the impact of interest rate fluctuations on its financial position. Furthermore, employing index-based strategies for the equity portion of the portfolio helps maintain diversification and manage risk, which is consistent with the investment policy statement's emphasis on a well-diversified portfolio. Index-based strategies provide broad market exposure and are cost-effective compared to actively managed strategies. The other two options are less suitable because: - Shifting the entire portfolio to a passive index-based approach equally weighted between fixed income and equity indices may not adequately address the duration gap and interest rate risk, which is a primary concern for the insurance company. - Maintaining the current 60/40 asset allocation with actively managed strategies that aim to outperform benchmarks and generate alpha may not prioritize the reduction of interest rate risk and could result in higher costs and less diversification compared to index-based strategies.

Go Premium

Chartered Financial Analyst Level 3 Preparation Package (2024)

  • 673 Superior-grade Chartered Financial Analyst Level 3 practice questions.
  • Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
  • Unlock Effortless CFA Level 3 preparation: 5 full exams.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
  • Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
  • Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!
More Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies questions
22 questions (total)
Start 22 question test