Back to Information Security Risk Response

Risk Treatment / Risk Response Options

5 minutes 5 Questions

In the context of CISM (Certified Information Security Manager) and Information Security Risk Response, Risk Treatment, also known as Risk Response, involves selecting and implementing measures to modify risk. The primary goal is to manage risks to an acceptable level, aligning with the organization’s risk appetite and strategic objectives. There are four main risk response options: Avoidance, Transfer, Mitigation, and Acceptance1. **Avoidance**: This strategy involves eliminating the risk by discontinuing the activities that generate it. For example, if a particular system poses significant security risks that cannot be adequately mitigated, the organization might choose to stop using that system altogether2. **Transfer**: Risk transfer shifts the responsibility of managing the risk to a third party. Common methods include outsourcing certain functions or purchasing insurance. While this doesn’t eliminate the risk, it can reduce the financial impact or liability associated with it3. **Mitigation**: Mitigation aims to reduce the likelihood or impact of the risk. This is often achieved through implementing controls such as firewalls, encryption, access controls, and regular security training for employees. Mitigation is typically the most preferred option as it directly addresses the risk while allowing business operations to continue4. **Acceptance**: Sometimes, the cost of mitigating a risk may outweigh the potential impact, leading an organization to accept the risk. This decision is based on a thorough risk assessment and an understanding that the risk falls within the organization’s risk tolerance levels. Acceptance requires continual monitoring to ensure that the risk remains manageableEffective risk treatment requires a comprehensive understanding of the organization’s assets, threats, vulnerabilities, and the potential impact of different risks. CISM-certified professionals play a crucial role in evaluating these options, recommending appropriate strategies, and ensuring that risk responses are aligned with the organization’s overall information security strategy. Additionally, continuous monitoring and review are essential to adapt to the evolving threat landscape and to ensure that the chosen risk response remains effective over time. By systematically addressing risks through these treatment options, organizations can enhance their resilience and protect their information assets more effectively.

Risk Treatment / Risk Response Options

Why it's important:
Understanding risk treatment and response options is crucial for effective information security management. It enables organizations to make informed decisions on how to handle identified risks and protect their assets.

What it is:
Risk treatment / response options are the strategies an organization can employ to address identified risks. These options typically include:
1. Risk Avoidance
2. Risk Reduction (Mitigation)
3. Risk Transfer
4. Risk Acceptance

How it works:
1. Risk Avoidance: Eliminating the risk by removing the asset or discontinuing the activity.
2. Risk Reduction: Implementing controls to minimize the likelihood or impact of the risk.
3. Risk Transfer: Shifting the risk to another party, such as through insurance or outsourcing.
4. Risk Acceptance: Acknowledging and tolerating the risk when it falls within the organization's risk appetite.

Answering exam questions:
1. Understand the context of the scenario presented.
2. Identify the risk and its potential impact.
3. Consider the organization's risk appetite and available resources.
4. Select the most appropriate risk treatment option based on the given information.
5. Justify your choice with clear reasoning.

Exam Tips:
1. Familiarize yourself with the four main risk treatment options.
2. Practice applying these options to various scenarios.
3. Consider cost-effectiveness and feasibility when selecting an option.
4. Remember that a combination of options may be appropriate in some cases.
5. Be prepared to explain the pros and cons of each option.
6. Pay attention to keywords in the question that may hint at the preferred response option.
7. Consider the long-term implications of each option, not just immediate effects.

Test mode:
Start practice test
CISM - Information Security Risk Response Example Questions

Test your knowledge of Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3)

Question 1

Which risk treatment option involves accepting the potential impact of a risk and taking no action to mitigate it?

Correct Answer: Risk acceptance

The correct answer is 'Risk acceptance'.

Risk acceptance is a strategy where an organization acknowledges the potential impact of a risk and decides not to take any action to mitigate it. This approach is typically used when the cost of addressing the risk outweighs the potential benefits, or when the risk is deemed acceptable given the organization's risk appetite.

Here's why the other options are incorrect:

'Risk avoidance' involves eliminating the risk entirely by not engaging in the activity that creates the risk. This is not the same as accepting the risk and taking no action.

'Risk transference' involves shifting the risk to another party, often through insurance or contractual agreements. This is an active strategy to manage risk, not a passive acceptance.

'Risk mitigation through controls' involves implementing measures to reduce the likelihood or impact of a risk. This is the opposite of accepting the risk and taking no action.

In the context of information security management, risk acceptance is a valid strategy when the risk is well understood, and the potential impact is deemed acceptable in relation to the cost or complexity of mitigating it. However, it's crucial for organizations to document their decision to accept a risk and regularly review this decision as part of their overall risk management process.

Question 2

Which risk treatment option involves transferring the financial consequences of a risk to another party?

Correct Answer: Risk transfer

Risk transfer is the correct answer for this question. It involves shifting the financial burden of a risk to another party, typically through insurance policies, contracts, or other financial instruments. This option allows an organization to manage risks that are beyond its risk appetite or capacity to handle internally. By transferring the financial consequences, the organization can protect itself from potentially significant losses. The other options are incorrect: Risk acceptance with contingency planning involves acknowledging and preparing for a risk, but not transferring its financial consequences. Risk avoidance through process redesign aims to eliminate the risk entirely by changing how an activity is performed, rather than transferring its financial impact. Risk mitigation by implementing controls focuses on reducing the likelihood or impact of a risk through various measures, but does not involve transferring financial consequences to another party.

Question 3

Which risk treatment option involves modifying the risk to achieve an acceptable level of impact or likelihood?

Correct Answer: Risk reduction

Risk reduction is the correct answer because it involves modifying the risk to achieve an acceptable level of impact or likelihood. This is a key aspect of risk management in information security. Risk reduction typically involves implementing controls or measures to decrease the probability or impact of a risk. This could include technical controls, administrative policies, or physical safeguards. The other options are incorrect: Risk avoidance is about eliminating the risk entirely, often by not engaging in the activity that creates the risk. This is different from modifying the risk to an acceptable level. Risk sharing through contractual agreements involves transferring part of the risk to another party, such as an insurance company. While this can be a valid strategy, it doesn't involve modifying the risk itself. Risk retention with contingency planning means accepting the risk as it is and preparing to deal with its consequences if it occurs. This approach doesn't involve modifying the risk to achieve an acceptable level.

Go Premium

CISM (Certified Information Security Manager) Preparation Package (2024)

  • 1010 Superior-grade CISM (Certified Information Security Manager) practice questions.
  • Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
  • Unlock Effortless CISM preparation: 5 full exams.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
  • Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
  • Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!
More Risk Treatment / Risk Response Options questions
25 questions (total)
Start 25 question test