Relationship to Other Frameworks and Standards
COBIT 2019 is designed to work synergistically with other major frameworks and standards, creating a comprehensive governance ecosystem. It complements ITIL, which focuses on service management practices, by providing governance oversight of IT service delivery. While ITIL details how to manage IT … COBIT 2019 is designed to work synergistically with other major frameworks and standards, creating a comprehensive governance ecosystem. It complements ITIL, which focuses on service management practices, by providing governance oversight of IT service delivery. While ITIL details how to manage IT services effectively, COBIT ensures these services align with business objectives and are properly governed. COBIT also integrates well with ISO/IEC 27001 and 27002 for information security management. Organizations can use COBIT's governance framework alongside ISO standards to establish robust security controls and compliance requirements. The relationship with COSO (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations) is significant, as COBIT incorporates COSO's internal control frameworks and enterprise risk management principles. This alignment helps organizations establish cohesive governance structures across IT and enterprise-wide operations. COBIT 2019 acknowledges CobiT frameworks like PMI's PMBOK for project management, enabling better integration of project governance within IT governance. Additionally, COBIT references ISO/IEC 38500 standards for corporate IT governance, strengthening the governance foundation. The framework is also compatible with agile and DevOps methodologies, allowing organizations pursuing modern development approaches to maintain governance standards. For compliance purposes, COBIT supports adherence to regulatory requirements such as SOX, GDPR, and HIPAA by providing control mechanisms and governance practices. The framework's flexibility allows organizations to tailor implementations based on their specific standards and regulatory environment. COBIT 2019's relationship with these frameworks creates an integrated approach to governance, enabling organizations to leverage multiple standards without creating conflicting processes or duplicate efforts. This interoperability makes COBIT a central hub for enterprise governance, allowing seamless coordination between IT service management, security management, risk management, and compliance requirements across the organization.
COBIT 2019 Foundation: Relationship to Other Frameworks and Standards
Understanding the Relationship to Other Frameworks and Standards
Why Is This Important?
Understanding how COBIT 2019 relates to other frameworks and standards is crucial for several reasons:
- Organizations often use multiple frameworks simultaneously (ISO/IEC 27001, ITIL, etc.)
- It helps professionals implement governance holistically across their organization
- It demonstrates how COBIT complements rather than replaces other standards
- It provides clarity on where COBIT fits in the broader ecosystem of governance and management frameworks
- It enables seamless integration of different frameworks without duplication or conflicts
- It's frequently tested in COBIT 2019 Foundation exams
What Is Relationship to Other Frameworks?
COBIT 2019 is designed as a comprehensive governance and management framework that works alongside other established frameworks rather than independently. The relationship encompasses:
- Complementary Positioning: COBIT provides the governance layer while other frameworks handle specific domains
- Integration Points: Clear mappings showing how COBIT practices align with other frameworks' requirements
- Mutual Support: Using multiple frameworks together creates a more robust, comprehensive control environment
- Standards Alignment: COBIT incorporates elements from ISO/IEC standards, ensuring consistency across frameworks
Key Frameworks and Standards COBIT Relates To:
1. ISO/IEC 27001 and ISO/IEC 27002
- Focus: Information Security Management
- Relationship: COBIT's governance processes align with ISO's security controls
- How They Work Together: ISO provides detailed security controls; COBIT provides governance oversight of these controls
- Key Mapping: COBIT governance processes support ISO security domains
2. ITIL (IT Service Management)
- Focus: Service delivery and operational management
- Relationship: COBIT governance framework encompasses ITIL service management practices
- How They Work Together: ITIL handles day-to-day service operations; COBIT provides strategic governance and oversight
- Key Mapping: COBIT's governance processes incorporate ITIL service management principles
3. ISO/IEC 38500 (IT Governance)
- Focus: Strategic IT governance and board-level oversight
- Relationship: COBIT 2019 is built upon and extends ISO/IEC 38500 principles
- How They Work Together: ISO 38500 provides high-level principles; COBIT provides detailed governance practices
- Key Mapping: COBIT implements the six principles of ISO 38500
4. NIST Cybersecurity Framework
- Focus: Cybersecurity risk management
- Relationship: COBIT's governance aligns with NIST's functions (Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond, Recover)
- How They Work Together: Both provide structured approaches to managing cybersecurity risks
- Key Mapping: COBIT governance processes map to NIST functions
5. ISO/IEC 31000 (Risk Management)
- Focus: Enterprise risk management
- Relationship: COBIT incorporates risk management principles aligned with ISO 31000
- How They Work Together: ISO 31000 provides risk framework; COBIT integrates risk governance
- Key Mapping: COBIT's governance processes embed ISO 31000 risk principles
6. Balanced Scorecard and Strategic Planning Frameworks
- Focus: Strategic performance management
- Relationship: COBIT incorporates balanced scorecard concepts for measuring governance effectiveness
- How They Work Together: COBIT uses balanced scorecard metrics for monitoring and optimization
How the Relationships Work in Practice:
The Governance Orchestration Model
COBIT acts as an orchestrator that brings together various frameworks:
- Strategic Layer: COBIT governance aligns organizational objectives with IT strategy
- Management Layer: COBIT practices incorporate operational frameworks like ITIL
- Control Layer: COBIT governance oversees specific controls from ISO 27001, NIST, etc.
- Compliance Layer: COBIT ensures alignment with all applicable standards simultaneously
Integration Without Duplication
- COBIT identifies which processes should be governed for each framework requirement
- Organizations select appropriate practices rather than implementing entire frameworks redundantly
- Cross-mapping ensures a single process can address multiple frameworks' requirements
- This approach reduces implementation burden and improves efficiency
Core Principles of Relationship Management:
- Complementary, Not Competitive: COBIT doesn't replace other frameworks; it coordinates their implementation
- Principle-Based Alignment: Relationships are built on shared principles and objectives
- Flexible Implementation: Organizations choose which frameworks to implement based on their context
- Coherent Governance: Multiple frameworks create a cohesive governance structure
- Risk-Based Selection: Framework choices align with organizational risk profile
Practical Examples of Relationships:
Example 1: Information Security Governance
- COBIT Process: APO13 (Manage Security)
- ISO 27001 Controls: Maps to multiple security domains
- NIST Framework: Align with Protect and Detect functions
- Integration: COBIT governance ensures ISO controls are implemented and NIST functions are managed
Example 2: Service Delivery Governance
- COBIT Process: BAI05 (Manage Organizational Change)
- ITIL Concepts: Change management processes
- Integration: COBIT governance oversees ITIL change management practices
Example 3: Risk Management Governance
- COBIT Process: APO12 (Manage Risk)
- ISO 31000: Risk management principles
- Integration: COBIT embeds ISO 31000 framework in governance processes
How to Answer Exam Questions on Relationship to Other Frameworks:
Step 1: Identify the Framework in Question
- Determine which framework or standard the question references (ISO 27001, ITIL, NIST, etc.)
- Recall the primary focus of that framework
- Consider which COBIT domain or process would relate to it
Step 2: Understand the Relationship Type
- Governance vs. Operational: COBIT provides governance; other frameworks often provide operational specifics
- Strategic vs. Tactical: COBIT addresses strategic governance; frameworks may focus on tactical implementation
- Principle-Based vs. Control-Based: COBIT's relationship is principle-based, not one-to-one control mapping
Step 3: Determine the Integration Point
- Where in COBIT would this framework's requirements be governed?
- Which COBIT processes address this framework's objectives?
- How does COBIT ensure the framework's requirements are met?
Step 4: Articulate How They Complement Each Other
- Explain what each framework brings to the organization
- Clarify that COBIT orchestrates rather than replaces
- Show how their combined implementation is stronger than separate efforts
Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Relationship to Other Frameworks and Standards
Tip 1: Remember COBIT's Role as Orchestrator
- COBIT doesn't replace other frameworks
- COBIT integrates and governs other frameworks
- When asked about relationships, think about how COBIT provides governance oversight
- Key phrases to use: "COBIT complements," "COBIT orchestrates," "COBIT governs the implementation of"
Tip 2: Know the Primary Purpose of Each Framework
- ISO 27001: Information security controls and compliance
- ITIL: IT service delivery and operational management
- ISO 38500: IT governance principles (COBIT is built on this)
- NIST: Cybersecurity risk management framework
- ISO 31000: Enterprise risk management principles
Tip 3: Distinguish Between Framework Levels
- Questions often test whether you understand governance (COBIT) vs. operational implementation (other frameworks)
- If the question asks about governance, COBIT is primary
- If the question asks about operational controls, COBIT governs while other frameworks implement
- Recognize questions asking about coordination and alignment (COBIT's role)
Tip 4: Use Process Mapping Knowledge
- Familiarize yourself with how COBIT processes align with key frameworks
- For example: APO13 relates to ISO 27001; BAI processes relate to ITIL concepts
- When answering, reference which COBIT process/domain addresses the framework's concern
- This demonstrates integrated understanding
Tip 5: Focus on Principle Alignment
- COBIT's relationship to other frameworks is based on shared principles, not one-to-one mapping
- When answering, emphasize principles rather than granular control matching
- Explain how COBIT principles support and enable other frameworks
- Show understanding that relationships are holistic, not merely technical
Tip 6: Watch for Trick Questions
- Wrong Answer Type: "COBIT replaces ITIL," "COBIT makes ISO 27001 unnecessary"
- Correct Approach: COBIT and other frameworks work together for comprehensive governance
- When you see "replaces" or "eliminates," it's likely a wrong answer
- Look for answers indicating complementary relationships
Tip 7: Understand the Context of Use
- Real organizations use COBIT alongside other frameworks
- Questions may ask how an organization uses COBIT with other frameworks
- The answer usually involves using COBIT for governance and other frameworks for specific domains
- Think about practical, integrated implementation rather than isolated framework use
Tip 8: Know the Coverage Differences
- COBIT is broader and strategic (governance focus)
- Other frameworks are often more specific (ISO 27001 = security, ITIL = service management)
- Questions may test whether you understand what each framework covers
- COBIT covers governance of IT, which includes multiple specific domains
Tip 9: Practice Common Question Patterns
Pattern 1: "Which COBIT process governs the implementation of [specific framework]?"
- Answer: Identify the relevant COBIT domain, then the specific process
- Example: "APO13 (Manage Security) provides governance for ISO 27001 implementation"
Pattern 2: "How does COBIT relate to [framework name]?"
- Answer: Explain the complementary relationship and governance role
- Example: "COBIT provides governance oversight; ITIL provides service management practices"
Pattern 3: "An organization uses both COBIT and [another framework]. Which is responsible for [specific activity]?"
- Answer: Consider whether the activity is governance or operational
- If governance-level: COBIT is likely responsible
- If operational: The specific framework is likely responsible, with COBIT providing oversight
Pattern 4: "Which statement best describes COBIT's relationship to ISO 27001?"
- Look for answers indicating complementary roles
- COBIT governs security governance; ISO 27001 provides specific controls
- Together they ensure comprehensive information security
Tip 10: Review ISO 38500 Relationship Carefully
- This is critical: COBIT 2019 is built upon ISO/IEC 38500
- Many exam questions test understanding of this foundational relationship
- COBIT extends and implements the 6 principles of ISO 38500
- When asked about COBIT's basis, reference ISO 38500
- Understand that COBIT is the practical implementation of ISO 38500 principles
Tip 11: Remember the Five COBIT Components
- When answering relationship questions, consider all five components: Processes, Organizational Structures, Culture/Ethics/Behavior, Information, and Services/Infrastructure/Applications
- Other frameworks may address only some components
- COBIT's holistic approach to governance encompasses what multiple frameworks address separately
Tip 12: Be Prepared for Scenario Questions
- Questions may present an organizational scenario requiring multiple frameworks
- Approach: Identify which framework addresses which requirement
- Then explain how COBIT coordinates their implementation
- Example: "A company needs security (ISO 27001), service management (ITIL), and governance (COBIT). How do they work together?"
- Answer: COBIT provides overarching governance; ISO 27001 and ITIL address specific operational domains under COBIT oversight
Sample Exam Questions and Approach:
Question 1: "Which statement best describes COBIT's relationship to ITIL?"
Approach: COBIT is governance layer; ITIL is operational layer. COBIT governs ITIL implementation.
Question 2: "An organization implements ISO 27001 controls. Which COBIT process would govern this implementation?"
Approach: APO13 (Manage Security) is the governance process for security, including ISO 27001 controls.
Question 3: "How does COBIT 2019 relate to ISO/IEC 38500?"
Approach: COBIT is built on ISO 38500 principles and provides their practical implementation.
Question 4: "Does implementing COBIT eliminate the need for NIST Cybersecurity Framework?"
Approach: No. COBIT governs governance of cybersecurity; NIST provides the cybersecurity management framework. Both are needed for comprehensive cybersecurity governance and management.
Final Exam Strategy:
- When unsure, ask: "Is this about governance (COBIT) or operations (other frameworks)?"
- Remember COBIT is the governance orchestrator, not a replacement
- Use the principle of complementarity—frameworks work together, not against each other
- Always emphasize the role of COBIT in governance and oversight
- Connect to real-world scenarios where organizations use multiple frameworks
- Focus on how COBIT provides the governance structure for implementing other frameworks
- Review the specific COBIT processes that relate to each major framework
- Practice distinguishing between strategic/governance (COBIT) and tactical/operational (other frameworks) questions
🎓 Unlock Premium Access
COBIT 2019 Foundation + ALL Certifications
- 🎓 Access to ALL Certifications: Study for any certification on our platform with one subscription
- 3680 Superior-grade COBIT 2019 Foundation practice questions
- Unlimited practice tests across all certifications
- Detailed explanations for every question
- COBIT Foundation: 5 full exams plus all other certification exams
- 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund if unsatisfied
- Risk-Free: 7-day free trial with all premium features!