Chase, Level, and Hybrid Production Strategies

Chase, Level, and Hybrid Production Strategies: A Comprehensive Guide for CPIM Exam Success

Introduction: Why Chase, Level, and Hybrid Strategies Matter

Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) is a critical process that aligns demand forecasts with production capabilities to balance customer service, inventory investment, and operational costs. At the heart of S&OP lies a fundamental decision: How should a company adjust its production to meet fluctuating demand? The answer typically falls into one of three strategies — Chase, Level, or Hybrid. Understanding these strategies is essential not only for the CPIM exam but also for real-world supply chain management. These strategies directly affect workforce stability, inventory carrying costs, customer service levels, and overall profitability.

Why These Strategies Are Important

Every business faces demand variability. Seasonal products, promotional campaigns, economic cycles, and market trends all create peaks and valleys in customer orders. Without a deliberate production strategy, companies risk:

• Excessive inventory that ties up capital and incurs holding costs
• Stockouts that erode customer satisfaction and market share
• Workforce instability that increases hiring/firing costs and damages morale
• Inefficient capacity utilization that raises per-unit production costs

Choosing the right production strategy (or combination of strategies) allows organizations to manage these trade-offs deliberately rather than reactively. For CPIM candidates, this topic appears prominently in the Planning and Inventory Management module and is frequently tested because it integrates concepts from demand management, capacity planning, inventory control, and workforce management.

========================================
1. THE CHASE STRATEGY
========================================

What It Is

The Chase Strategy (also called the Chase Demand Strategy) adjusts production output in each period to exactly match (or "chase") the forecasted demand. When demand rises, production increases; when demand falls, production decreases. The goal is to keep finished goods inventory at a minimum or near-zero level.

How It Works

• Production rate is varied each period to align with the demand forecast.
• The workforce is expanded (hiring) during high-demand periods and contracted (layoffs) during low-demand periods.
• Alternatively, instead of changing headcount, companies may use overtime, temporary workers, or subcontracting to vary output.
• Finished goods inventory is kept minimal because production closely mirrors demand.

Key Characteristics:

• Inventory levels: Low (minimal or zero finished goods buffer)
• Workforce: Variable — frequent hiring, layoffs, overtime adjustments
• Production rate: Changes every period to match demand
• Primary cost drivers: Hiring costs, firing/layoff costs, overtime premiums, training costs, subcontracting costs
• Customer service: Generally high if execution is effective, since production targets match demand

Advantages:

• Minimizes inventory carrying costs
• Reduces risk of obsolescence (especially important for perishable or fashion goods)
• Inventory investment is kept low, freeing up working capital
• Responsive to actual market demand

Disadvantages:

• High costs associated with hiring, training, and laying off workers
• Workforce morale issues due to job insecurity
• Potential quality problems when using inexperienced temporary workers
• May face capacity constraints during peak periods
• Subcontracting may reduce quality control
• Higher administrative burden to constantly adjust resources

Best Suited For:

• Industries with highly seasonal or unpredictable demand
• Products with high holding costs or short shelf life (e.g., food, fashion)
• Environments where labor is flexible and readily available
• Make-to-order (MTO) environments

========================================
2. THE LEVEL STRATEGY
========================================

What It Is

The Level Strategy (also called the Level Production Strategy) maintains a constant production rate and/or a stable workforce over the planning horizon, regardless of demand fluctuations. Inventory and/or order backlogs absorb the differences between production and demand.

How It Works

• Production output remains the same in every period (or nearly so).
• The workforce is kept stable — no significant hiring or layoffs.
• During periods when demand is below the production rate, excess output goes into finished goods inventory (building up a buffer).
• During periods when demand is above the production rate, inventory is drawn down to fulfill orders. If inventory is insufficient, backlogs or backorders may accumulate.
• The constant production rate is typically set at the average demand over the planning horizon.

Key Characteristics:

• Inventory levels: High — inventory builds during low-demand periods
• Workforce: Stable — consistent headcount throughout the year
• Production rate: Constant (usually equal to average demand)
• Primary cost drivers: Inventory carrying costs (storage, insurance, obsolescence, capital), potential backorder costs
• Customer service: Risk of stockouts during peak demand if inventory buffer is insufficient

Advantages:

• Stable workforce leads to better morale, lower turnover, and higher skill levels
• Predictable production schedules simplify planning and scheduling
• Consistent utilization of equipment and facilities
• Lower hiring, training, and layoff costs
• Easier to maintain quality standards with an experienced, stable workforce

Disadvantages:

• High inventory carrying costs
• Risk of product obsolescence, especially for products with short life cycles
• Capital is tied up in inventory
• Potential for stockouts during demand peaks if inventory is insufficient
• Requires accurate long-range demand forecasting
• May require significant warehouse space

Best Suited For:

• Industries where labor costs (hiring/firing) are very high or labor is scarce
• Products with long shelf life and low obsolescence risk
• Environments where demand variability is moderate
• Make-to-stock (MTS) environments
• Organizations that prioritize workforce stability (e.g., unionized environments)

========================================
3. THE HYBRID (MIXED) STRATEGY
========================================

What It Is

The Hybrid Strategy (also called a Mixed Strategy) combines elements of both the chase and level strategies. It seeks to balance the trade-offs by using a combination of inventory buffers, workforce adjustments, overtime, subcontracting, and demand management techniques.

How It Works

• The company maintains a relatively stable workforce but allows for some flexibility (e.g., limited overtime or part-time workers).
• Some inventory is built up in anticipation of demand peaks, but not to the full extent a pure level strategy would require.
• Production rate may be adjusted in steps rather than continuously tracking demand.
• Demand management tools (pricing, promotions, backlog management) may be used to smooth demand patterns.
• Subcontracting may be used selectively during extreme peaks.

Key Characteristics:

• Inventory levels: Moderate — some buffer but less than pure level
• Workforce: Relatively stable with some flexibility (overtime, temps)
• Production rate: Adjusted periodically but not every period
• Primary cost drivers: A blend of inventory costs, overtime costs, and limited hiring/subcontracting costs
• Customer service: Balanced approach aims for good service with manageable costs

Advantages:

• More realistic and practical than either pure strategy
• Balances costs across multiple cost categories rather than concentrating risk in one area
• Offers flexibility to respond to demand changes while maintaining some stability
• Can be tailored to the specific cost structure and constraints of the organization
• Most commonly used in practice

Disadvantages:

• More complex to plan and manage
• Requires sophisticated analysis to find the optimal blend
• May not fully optimize any single cost element
• Harder to communicate and implement consistently across the organization

Best Suited For:

• Most real-world manufacturing environments
• Organizations with moderate demand variability
• Companies that want to balance workforce stability with inventory cost control
• Environments with multiple product lines having different demand patterns

========================================
COMPARISON SUMMARY TABLE
========================================

Chase Strategy:
- Production Rate: Variable (matches demand)
- Inventory: Low/Minimal
- Workforce: Variable (hire/fire)
- Main Cost: Workforce changes
- Best When: Demand is highly variable, holding costs are high

Level Strategy:
- Production Rate: Constant (average demand)
- Inventory: High (builds buffer)
- Workforce: Stable
- Main Cost: Inventory carrying
- Best When: Workforce costs are high, demand is moderate

Hybrid Strategy:
- Production Rate: Adjusted periodically
- Inventory: Moderate
- Workforce: Mostly stable with some flex
- Main Cost: Balanced across categories
- Best When: Practical balance is needed

========================================
HOW TO CALCULATE AND ANALYZE THESE STRATEGIES
========================================

Step-by-Step Approach for Exam Problems:

For Chase Strategy calculations:
1. Identify the demand forecast for each period.
2. Set production in each period equal to the demand for that period.
3. Calculate the workforce changes needed each period (hires and layoffs).
4. Calculate total cost = Σ (hiring costs + layoff costs + production costs + any overtime/subcontracting costs).
5. Ending inventory each period should be approximately zero (or at a target safety stock level).

For Level Strategy calculations:
1. Calculate total demand over the planning horizon.
2. Divide total demand by the number of periods to get the constant production rate (average demand).
3. For each period, calculate: Ending Inventory = Beginning Inventory + Production − Demand.
4. Track cumulative inventory (or backlog if inventory goes negative).
5. Calculate total cost = Σ (inventory carrying costs + backorder costs + constant production costs).
6. Ensure the workforce is sized to support the constant production rate.

For Hybrid Strategy calculations:
1. Define the rules (e.g., base production rate with overtime up to X%, subcontracting allowed for demand above Y).
2. For each period, apply the rules to determine production from regular time, overtime, and subcontracting.
3. Calculate inventory balances each period.
4. Sum all relevant costs: regular production + overtime premiums + subcontracting costs + inventory carrying costs + any hiring/firing costs.

Important Formula Reminders:

Ending Inventory = Beginning Inventory + Production − Demand

Average Inventory = (Beginning Inventory + Ending Inventory) / 2

Inventory Carrying Cost = Average Inventory × Carrying Cost per Unit per Period

Workers Needed = Production Required / Output per Worker per Period

Workers to Hire = Workers Needed This Period − Workers Available from Last Period (if positive)

Workers to Lay Off = Workers Available from Last Period − Workers Needed This Period (if positive)

========================================
EXAM TIPS: ANSWERING QUESTIONS ON CHASE, LEVEL, AND HYBRID PRODUCTION STRATEGIES
========================================

Tip 1: Identify the Strategy from Its Description
Many exam questions describe a scenario without naming the strategy. Look for these clues:
- If production changes every period to match demand → Chase
- If production stays the same every period and inventory fluctuates → Level
- If there is a base production rate with overtime, subcontracting, or moderate inventory → Hybrid

Tip 2: Know the Cost Trade-Offs Cold
The exam frequently asks which strategy minimizes a particular cost. Remember:
- Chase minimizes inventory costs but increases workforce change costs
- Level minimizes workforce change costs but increases inventory carrying costs
- Hybrid tries to minimize total costs by blending approaches

Tip 3: Connect Strategy to Environment
When asked which strategy is most appropriate for a given situation:
- Perishable goods, high holding costs, flexible labor market → Chase
- Expensive to hire/fire, unionized workforce, long product shelf life → Level
- Most real-world situations, moderate variability → Hybrid

Tip 4: Watch for Backorder and Backlog Questions
In a level strategy, if production is set at average demand and there is no beginning inventory, there will be periods where demand exceeds cumulative production — resulting in backlogs. The exam may ask you to identify when backlogs occur or calculate backorder costs.

Tip 5: Read Quantitative Problems Carefully
For calculation questions:
- Pay attention to units: cost per unit per month vs. per year
- Check whether they ask for ending inventory or average inventory
- Note if there is a beginning inventory or target ending inventory
- Determine if backorders are allowed or if the question specifies no stockouts
- Track cumulative production vs. cumulative demand to check feasibility

Tip 6: Understand the Role of Demand Management
The exam may reference demand management techniques (pricing, promotions, reservations) as part of a hybrid strategy. Shifting demand from peak to off-peak periods effectively reduces the need for extreme chase or level approaches.

Tip 7: Remember the Planning Hierarchy
These strategies exist at the aggregate planning level (S&OP), not at the detailed scheduling level. Questions may test whether you understand that these are medium-term, family-level production plans — not item-level MPS decisions.

Tip 8: Process of Elimination on Multiple Choice
If a question asks for the primary advantage of the level strategy, eliminate answers about low inventory or flexible response to demand — those are chase characteristics. The primary advantage of level is workforce stability and predictable production.

Tip 9: Hybrid Is Usually the "Real World" Answer
When the exam describes a practical, real-world scenario and asks which approach is most commonly used, the answer is almost always Hybrid. Pure chase and pure level are theoretical extremes.

Tip 10: Link to Capacity and Resource Planning
Remember that production strategies must be feasible within capacity constraints. A chase strategy requires flexible capacity. A level strategy requires sufficient storage capacity for inventory buildup. The exam may test whether a proposed strategy is feasible given stated constraints.

Tip 11: Don't Confuse Chase with Make-to-Order
While chase strategy aligns well with MTO environments, they are not the same concept. Chase is an aggregate production strategy; MTO is a manufacturing environment/order fulfillment strategy. The exam may try to blur this distinction.

Tip 12: Practice Total Cost Comparison Problems
A classic exam question provides demand data, cost parameters, and asks you to calculate total cost under two or three strategies to determine which is least costly. Practice setting up the period-by-period table: Period | Demand | Production | Inventory | Hire | Layoff | Costs. Speed and accuracy in these tabular calculations are essential.

========================================
FINAL SUMMARY
========================================

The choice among Chase, Level, and Hybrid strategies represents one of the most important decisions in Sales and Operations Planning. Each strategy presents distinct cost profiles and operational implications:

• Chase = Match production to demand = Low inventory, high workforce variability
• Level = Constant production rate = High inventory, stable workforce
• Hybrid = Best of both worlds = Moderate inventory, moderate flexibility

For the CPIM exam, focus on understanding the conceptual trade-offs, being able to identify strategies from descriptions, calculating total costs for each approach, and recommending the appropriate strategy based on a given business scenario. Mastering this topic will serve you well not only on the exam but in your professional supply chain career.