Collective Decision Making

Correct Answer: Use a collaborative decision-making technique to weigh the advantages and risks, to drive a consensus.

The most suitable move when dealing with such a situation, according to Agile principles, is to engage in a collaborative decision-making process. This involves weighing the tool's benefits against the potential risks and striving to reach a consensus within the team. This reflects the Agile philosophy of encouraging shared responsibility and making collective choices. The other options suggested are not typically in line with Agile principles. The idea of approving the tool without analyzing the risk doesn't promote the principle of Sustainable Development, which emphasizes maintaining a constant pace and well-being for the team. Completely ignoring the proposal due to its risky nature goes against the principle of welcoming changing requirements, even late in development, as Agile processes harness change for the customer's competitive advantage. Deciding individually without the team's input is not in line with Agile's emphasis on individuals and interactions, and undermines the concept of self-organizing teams. Therefore, these alternatives are not the best course of action in this circumstance.

Correct Answer: Encourage open discussion and collaboration among the team, helping them reach a consensus.

The best approach for a PMI Agile Practitioner to resolve disagreement among the team on a complex issue is to: 'Encourage open discussion and collaboration among the team, helping them reach a consensus.' This method aligns with the Agile principle of self-organizing teams, where team members collaboratively decide on the best solution. The other approaches are not advisable: Making a decision based on personal experience and imposing it does not promote collaboration and might lead to resentment among the team members. Asking higher management to decide can undermine the team's self-organizing quality and flip a coin reflects a lack of commitment to finding the best solution, and could lead to sub-optimal results.

Correct Answer: Facilitate a collaborative decision-making process where both the proponents discuss pros, cons and impacts, leading to an informed collective decision.

As an Agile Practitioner, a key current industry best practice is to facilitate a collaborative decision-making process. This means, instead of enforcing your own decision, picking the easier feature or delegating the decision to an external party, the ideal approach is to have both the proponents discussing the pros, the cons, and the impacts of both the features. This empowers the team, fosters collaboration and often results in an informed collective decision. Other options either inhibit collective decision making(coerce) or may lead to a less optimal decision (accelerated choice based on easiness or external delegation).