Alternatives Analysis
Alternatives analysis is a systematic approach used in Business Case Development and Validation to evaluate different options for achieving a business objective. This process involves identifying, comparing, and assessing multiple strategies or solutions to determine the most effective and feasible approach. The primary goal of alternatives analysis is to ensure that the selected solution provides the best balance between benefits, costs, risks, and alignment with organizational goals. It encourages critical thinking and creativity by considering various scenarios, including conventional and unconventional options. During this analysis, each alternative is evaluated based on predefined criteria such as financial impact, time to implement, resource requirements, potential risks, and expected outcomes. Quantitative methods like cost-benefit analysis, as well as qualitative assessments, are often employed to provide a comprehensive evaluation. Incorporating alternatives analysis into the business case enhances its robustness by demonstrating that due diligence has been performed. It shows stakeholders that multiple pathways have been considered and that the recommended solution is not just viable but also optimal among available options. This process can also uncover innovative approaches that may offer greater value or highlight issues with initially preferred solutions. Alternatives analysis supports transparent decision-making and helps build consensus among stakeholders. By clearly presenting the pros and cons of each option, it facilitates informed discussions and aids in addressing concerns or objections. It also provides a contingency by identifying backup options should the primary plan encounter obstacles during implementation. In summary, alternatives analysis is a vital concept that strengthens Business Case Development and Validation. It ensures that organizations are not narrowly focusing on a single solution but are instead considering a range of possibilities to achieve the best possible outcome.
Alternatives Analysis in Business Case Development
Why Alternatives Analysis is Important
Alternatives Analysis is a critical component of business case development because it:
- Prevents premature commitment to a single solution
- Demonstrates due diligence in decision-making
- Helps identify optimal ways to deliver value
- Provides a structured approach to comparing various options
- Addresses stakeholder concerns by showing multiple options were considered
- Improves the quality of business decisions by exploring diverse perspectives
What is Alternatives Analysis?
Alternatives Analysis is a systematic evaluation of different options to solve a business problem or address an opportunity. In the context of business analysis and project management, it involves:
- Identifying various possible solutions
- Establishing evaluation criteria
- Comparing options objectively
- Recommending the best approach based on established criteria
As a PMI-PBA (Professional in Business Analysis), understanding this process is essential for developing comprehensive business cases that support sound decision-making.
How Alternatives Analysis Works
1. Identify Alternatives
Start by brainstorming potential solutions. These might include:
- Build vs. buy decisions
- Different implementation approaches
- Varying scopes of functionality
- Different vendors or technologies
- "Do nothing" option (always include as a baseline)
2. Establish Evaluation Criteria
Define factors for comparing options, such as:
- Cost (initial and ongoing)
- Timeline to implement
- Organizational impact
- Risk profile
- Technical feasibility
- Alignment with strategic objectives
- Expected benefits
3. Weight the Criteria
Not all criteria are equally important. Assign weights to reflect priorities.
4. Score Each Alternative
Evaluate each option against the criteria, often using matrices or scoring systems.
5. Analyze Results
Calculate weighted scores, consider qualitative factors, and identify trade-offs.
6. Recommend Preferred Alternative
Based on the analysis, recommend the best option to include in the business case.
Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Alternatives Analysis
Understanding Question Types
PMI-PBA exam questions on Alternatives Analysis typically focus on:
- The process steps
- How to evaluate options objectively
- Common techniques (decision matrices, cost-benefit analysis)
- Stakeholder involvement in the process
Key Concepts to Master
- Weighted scoring models
- Feasibility analysis
- Cost-benefit analysis
- Decision matrices
- SWOT analysis applied to alternatives
- Stakeholder impact assessment
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Selecting an answer that skips thorough analysis
- Choosing options that fail to consider multiple alternatives
- Selecting answers that only focus on cost rather than balanced criteria
- Picking options that omit the "do nothing" alternative
Approach to Scenario Questions
- Read carefully to identify if the question is about the process or application of Alternatives Analysis
- Look for clues about which stage of analysis is being described
- Pay attention to stakeholder considerations
- Remember that objectivity and comprehensive evaluation are key principles
Formula for Success
1. Identify the decision that needs to be made
2. Ensure multiple viable alternatives are considered
3. Use appropriate evaluation criteria that align with business value
4. Apply structured techniques rather than intuition
5. Document the rationale for the recommended approach
Remember that Alternatives Analysis is not about justifying a pre-determined solution but about objectively identifying the best path forward based on defined criteria.
Go Premium
PMI Professional in Business Analysis Preparation Package (2025)
- 3015 Superior-grade PMI Professional in Business Analysis practice questions.
- Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
- Unlock Effortless PMI-PBA preparation: 5 full exams.
- 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
- Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
- Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!