Lead and Lag Times and Their Effect on the Critical Path
Lead and lag times are essential components in the Critical Path Method (CPM) that allow project managers to fine-tune activity relationships and model real-world scheduling scenarios more accurately. By adjusting the timing of successor activities relative to their predecessors, leads and lags provide flexibility in scheduling and can impact the overall project duration and the critical path. **Lead Time** involves accelerating the start of a successor activity relative to its predecessor. A lead allows the successor activity to begin before the predecessor has fully completed, effectively creating an overlap between the two activities. Leads are represented as negative lag in scheduling software. For instance, in software development, testing (successor) might begin two days before coding (predecessor) is fully completed, applying a two-day lead. This overlap can shorten the overall project duration but may introduce risks if the preceding work is not sufficiently complete to support the successor’s progress. **Lag Time** introduces a delay between the predecessor and successor activities. It forces a waiting period after the predecessor is complete before the successor begins. Lags are used to represent processes that require time but do not require resources, such as curing concrete or waiting for approvals. An example of lag time is when a coating applied to a material must dry for 24 hours before the next process can begin. Here, a one-day lag is added to the schedule to account for this waiting period. **Effect on the Critical Path:** Incorporating leads and lags can significantly affect the critical path of a project. By introducing leads, activities may start earlier, potentially shortening the project duration and altering which sequence of activities is critical. Conversely, adding lags can delay successor activities, potentially extending the project duration and shifting the critical path to a different sequence of activities. Misapplication of leads and lags can cause schedule inaccuracies. For example, overly optimistic leads might not account for dependencies adequately, resulting in rework or quality issues. Excessive lags might introduce unnecessary delays and reduce schedule efficiency. Project managers must carefully analyze the necessity and impact of leads and lags, ensuring they are justified and documented. This involves collaborating with team members to assess the feasibility of overlaps or delays and evaluating the associated risks. **Best Practices:** - Use leads and lags sparingly and only when they accurately represent the logical relationship between activities. - Clearly document the rationale for applying leads and lags to facilitate understanding among stakeholders. - Monitor activities with leads and lags closely during project execution to manage risks associated with overlaps and delays. - Evaluate the impact on resource allocation, as leads and lags can affect resource demand profiles and potentially cause over-allocation or underutilization. By effectively managing lead and lag times, project managers can create realistic and efficient schedules that reflect the complexities of project execution, optimize timelines, and ensure that the critical path accurately represents the project's constraints.
Lead and Lag Times and Their Effect on the Critical Path
Why Lead and Lag Times are Important in Project Management
Lead and lag times are crucial components in project scheduling that can significantly impact the critical path. Understanding these concepts allows project managers to:
• Create more realistic project schedules
• Optimize resource allocation
• Identify opportunities to compress schedules
• Accurately calculate float and slack
• Better manage dependencies between activities
What are Lead and Lag Times?
Lead Time: A lead time creates an overlap between activities. It allows a successor activity to start before its predecessor has completely finished. Lead time is expressed as a negative value in most scheduling tools.
Example: If Activity B can start when Activity A is 75% complete, we would apply a 25% lead time to the relationship.
Lag Time: A lag time creates a delay between activities. It requires a waiting period after a predecessor activity finishes before the successor can begin. Lag time is expressed as a positive value.
Example: If concrete needs to cure for 3 days after pouring before construction can continue, we would apply a 3-day lag time.
How Lead and Lag Times Work in Critical Path Analysis
1. Impact on Dependency Relationships: Lead and lag times modify the four dependency types (Finish-to-Start, Start-to-Start, Finish-to-Finish, Start-to-Finish).
2. Calculation Effects: When calculating the critical path, lead times reduce the total duration between linked activities, while lag times increase it.
3. Network Diagram Representation: In network diagrams, lead and lag times are typically noted on the dependency arrows between activities.
4. Float/Slack Calculation: Lead and lag times are factored into float calculations, potentially changing which activities have zero float (critical path).
How Lead and Lag Times Affect the Critical Path
• Path Duration Change: Adding lag times to activities on the critical path extends the project duration.
• Critical Path Shift: Adding sufficient lag to activities can cause a different path to become critical.
• Schedule Compression: Introducing or increasing lead times can shorten the critical path.
• Resource Leveling Effects: Lead and lag times can be adjusted during resource leveling, potentially changing the critical path.
Practical Application in Project Scheduling
When building a schedule:
1. Identify necessary leads and lags based on:
• Technical requirements (curing time, cooling periods)
• Resource constraints
• External dependencies
• Regulatory requirements
2. Apply leads and lags to the appropriate relationship types:
• FS (Finish-to-Start): Most common for both leads and lags
• SS (Start-to-Start): Often used with lag for staggered starts
• FF (Finish-to-Finish): Can use lead to ensure concurrent completion
• SF (Start-to-Finish): Rarely used but may incorporate leads/lags
3. Recalculate the critical path after applying leads and lags
4. Analyze the impact on project duration and milestone dates
Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Lead and Lag Times
• Know the Definitions: Be clear that lead creates overlap (negative time) while lag creates delay (positive time).
• Calculation Practice: Practice calculating schedule impacts with various lead/lag scenarios.
• Critical Path Identification: In questions with network diagrams, recalculate the critical path when leads/lags are added or modified.
• Terminology Precision: Remember that some questions may use terms like "waiting time" for lag or "overlap" for lead.
• Context Matters: Analyze whether a lead or lag is appropriate based on the scenario's technical requirements.
• Multiple Impacts: Consider how changes to leads/lags might affect resource allocation and cost, not just schedule.
• Watch for Traps: Some exam questions may try to confuse leads and lags or misrepresent their impact.
• Units Matter: Be careful about the units (hours, days, weeks) when calculating lead/lag effects.
Sample Question Types
1. Calculation questions: "If Activity B has a FS relationship with Activity A and a 2-day lag, and Activity A finishes on day 10, when will Activity B start?"
2. Critical path identification: "After adding the specified leads and lags, which path becomes critical?"
3. Schedule compression: "How much can the project duration be reduced by changing the 3-day lag to a 1-day lead?"
4. Concept application: "What type of relationship with lag would best represent the need for concrete to cure for 5 days?"
Remember that on the PMP or PMI-SP exam, questions about lead and lag times often appear in the context of broader schedule management scenarios, so understanding how they interact with other scheduling concepts is essential.
Go Premium
PMI Scheduling Professional Preparation Package (2025)
- 3429 Superior-grade PMI Scheduling Professional practice questions.
- Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
- Unlock Effortless PMI-SP preparation: 5 full exams.
- 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
- Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
- Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!