Resource Overallocation and Underallocation
Resource overallocation occurs when a resource is assigned more work than can be completed within a given time period, exceeding their capacity. Underallocation, conversely, happens when a resource is not assigned enough work, leading to inefficiencies and increased project costs due to idle time. Both scenarios can negatively impact project performance, schedules, and budgets. Managing resource overallocation is critical to prevent burnout, missed deadlines, and compromised quality. Project managers must identify overallocated resources and take corrective actions such as redistributing workloads, delaying non-critical tasks, or bringing in additional resources. Techniques like resource leveling can be employed to adjust the schedule and alleviate overallocation by balancing resource demand with availability. Underallocation represents an opportunity cost where resources are not utilized to their full potential. Identifying underutilized resources allows project managers to reassign them to other tasks or projects, optimizing productivity. This can lead to cost savings and a more efficient use of the organization's human capital. Tools like resource histograms and leveling graphs are commonly used to visualize resource allocation over time, making it easier to spot periods of overallocation or underallocation. Regular monitoring and communication with team members are essential to stay informed about actual workload versus planned assignments. Adjustments should be made proactively to keep the project on track. In multi-project environments, resource overallocation and underallocation become more complex due to the interdependencies between projects. Implementing a centralized resource management system can help in coordinating resource assignments across projects, ensuring that resources are optimally allocated and conflicts are minimized. In conclusion, understanding and addressing resource overallocation and underallocation is a fundamental aspect of resource allocation and leveling. Effective management of resource assignments leads to improved project outcomes, balanced workloads, and enhanced team performance.
Guide to Resource Overallocation and Underallocation in PMI-SP
Understanding Resource Overallocation and Underallocation
Resource overallocation and underallocation are critical concepts in project scheduling and resource management. They refer to situations where resources (people, equipment, materials) are either assigned more work than their capacity (overallocation) or not utilized to their full potential (underallocation).
Why It's Important
Understanding and managing resource allocation is vital because:
• Overallocation leads to burnout, decreased quality, missed deadlines, and increased costs
• Underallocation results in wasted resources, decreased ROI, and potentially missed opportunities
• Proper resource management is essential for project success and stakeholder satisfaction
• It's a core component of the PMI-SP certification and effective schedule management
How Resource Allocation Works
Identifying Overallocation:
• Occurs when resources are assigned more work than they can handle in given timeframes
• Often appears as resource utilization exceeding 100%
• Can be identified in resource histograms as peaks above capacity lines
• Signs include missed deadlines, quality issues, and team fatigue
Identifying Underallocation:
• Occurs when resources are not fully utilized during project timeframes
• Appears as resource utilization below optimal capacity (often below 80-85%)
• Shows in resource histograms as valleys or gaps
• Results in idle resources and higher than necessary project costs
Managing Resource Allocation Issues
Addressing Overallocation:
1. Resource Leveling: Adjusting start and finish dates to resolve overallocation, potentially extending project duration
2. Resource Smoothing: Adjusting activities within float limits to resolve peaks while maintaining end date
3. Adding Resources: Bringing in additional team members or equipment
4. Adjusting Scope: Modifying project requirements to match available resources
5. Task Splitting: Breaking tasks to allow partial completion before interruption
Addressing Underallocation:
1. Resource Optimization: Reassigning underutilized resources to other projects
2. Fast-tracking: Performing activities in parallel that were planned sequentially
3. Skill Development: Training resources for additional responsibilities
4. Schedule Compression: Shortening duration to increase resource utilization
Tools and Techniques
• Resource histograms and S-curves for visualization
• Resource leveling heuristics (allocation based on priorities)
• Critical path analysis to identify scheduling flexibility
• Resource calendars to accurately represent availability
• Project management software for automated detection and resolution
Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Resource Overallocation and Underallocation
1. Know the indicators: Recognize signs of over/underallocation in various formats (graphs, scenarios, reports)
2. Understand the impacts: Be prepared to identify consequences of poor resource allocation on project constraints (time, cost, scope, quality)
3. Prioritize solutions: Questions often ask for the "best" approach - generally, solutions that maintain scope and quality while minimizing schedule impact are preferred
4. Remember context matters: Consider project type, constraints, and environment when selecting allocation strategies
5. Focus on terminology: Know the differences between resource leveling, smoothing, and other techniques
6. Calculate allocation percentages: Practice calculating utilization rates and identifying threshold percentages
7. Connect to other knowledge areas: Understand how resource allocation relates to risk management, stakeholder management, and schedule control
8. Recognize trade-offs: Questions may ask you to evaluate pros and cons of different allocation approaches
Remember that for the PMI-SP exam, you need to approach resource allocation from a scheduling perspective, focusing on how allocation issues impact the project schedule and how scheduling techniques can resolve resource conflicts.
Go Premium
PMI Scheduling Professional Preparation Package (2025)
- 3429 Superior-grade PMI Scheduling Professional practice questions.
- Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
- Unlock Effortless PMI-SP preparation: 5 full exams.
- 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
- Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
- Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!