Back to Employment Law

Disparate treatment

5 minutes 5 Questions

Disparate treatment is a legal concept in employment law and a crucial topic for SHRM Certified Professionals to understand. It refers to a situation where an employee or job applicant is treated differently based on protected characteristics such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, or genetic information. This form of discrimination occurs when individuals are intentionally treated less favorably because of these protected attributes, violating laws like Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA)In the workplace, disparate treatment can manifest in various ways, including hiring practices, promotions, job assignments, training opportunities, compensation, and termination decisions. For example, if a qualified female candidate is passed over for a promotion in favor of a less qualified male colleague solely because of gender, this constitutes disparate treatment. Similarly, if an employer enforces dress codes that disproportionately affect employees of a particular religion without a valid business reason, it may be seen as discriminatoryTo establish a disparate treatment claim, the plaintiff must demonstrate that they belong to a protected class, were qualified for the job or promotion, suffered an adverse employment action, and that the action was taken because of their protected characteristic. Employers can defend against such claims by providing legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons for their actionsFor SHRM Certified Professionals, understanding disparate treatment is essential for developing fair employment practices, conducting unbiased hiring processes, and ensuring compliance with anti-discrimination laws. This knowledge helps in creating inclusive workplaces, mitigating legal risks, and fostering a culture of equity and respect. Additionally, professionals must be adept at recognizing potential disparate treatment scenarios and implementing training and policies that promote equal opportunity and prevent discriminatory behavior in all aspects of employment.

Comprehensive Guide to Disparate Treatment in Employment Law

Introduction

Disparate Treatment is a critical concept in employment law, addressing intentional discrimination against employees based on protected characteristics.

Why Disparate Treatment is Important
Understanding disparate treatment is essential for fostering fair workplace practices and ensuring compliance with federal and state anti-discrimination laws.

What is Disparate Treatment?
Disparate treatment occurs when an employer treats an employee or job applicant differently based on characteristics such as race, gender, age, religion, or disability.

How Disparate Treatment Works
To establish a disparate treatment claim, the plaintiff must demonstrate that:
1. They belong to a protected class.
2. They were qualified for the position.
3. They were subjected to an adverse employment action.
4. Similarly situated individuals outside the protected class were treated more favorably.

Answering Exam Questions on Disparate Treatment
When tackling exam questions on disparate treatment:
1. **Identify the protected class** involved.
2. **Analyze the treatment** of the employee compared to others.
3. **Assess the employer’s justification** and its validity.
4. **Apply relevant laws** and precedents.

Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Disparate Treatment

  • Read the question carefully to identify all relevant facts and legal issues.
  • Structure your answer clearly, addressing each element of disparate treatment step-by-step.
  • Use legal terminology appropriately to demonstrate your understanding.
  • Provide examples to illustrate your points effectively.
  • Stay concise and focused on answering the question directly.

Test mode:
Start practice test
SHRM-CP - Employment Law Example Questions

Test your knowledge of Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3)

Question 1

A manager consistently promotes employees from a specific ethnic background over equally qualified candidates from other backgrounds. This behavior is an example of:

Correct Answer: Disparate Treatment

The correct answer is 'Disparate Treatment' because the manager is intentionally favoring employees of a specific ethnic background over equally qualified candidates from other backgrounds, which constitutes direct discrimination. 'Disparate Impact' refers to policies that are not intentionally discriminatory but have a disproportionate effect on a protected group. 'Hostile Work Environment' involves creating a work atmosphere that is intimidating or abusive, which is not the case here. 'Reverse Discrimination' is a non-legal term often used to describe perceived discrimination against majority groups, but it does not accurately describe the scenario provided.

Question 2

A company requires all applicants to adhere to a specific religion to perform job tasks, even though religion is irrelevant to the role. This requirement is an example of:

Correct Answer: Disparate treatment

The correct answer is 'Disparate treatment' because the company is intentionally requiring applicants to adhere to a specific religion, which constitutes direct discrimination based on religion. This is different from 'Disparate impact,' which involves policies that are not intentionally discriminatory but have a discriminatory effect. 'Hostile work environment' refers to creating a workplace that is intimidating or abusive based on protected characteristics, which is not the case here. Lastly, 'Retaliation' involves taking adverse action against someone for engaging in protected activities, which does not apply to this scenario.

Question 3

Which of the following best represents disparate treatment in an employment context?

Correct Answer: An employer denies training opportunities to employees based on their nationality.

Disparate treatment occurs when an employer takes adverse action against an individual based on protected characteristics, such as nationality. Denying training opportunities based on nationality exemplifies intentional discrimination. The other options describe either legitimate business practices or non-discriminatory actions, which do not constitute disparate treatment.

Go Premium

SHRM Certified Professional Preparation Package (2024)

  • 4708 Superior-grade SHRM Certified Professional practice questions.
  • Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
  • Unlock Effortless SHRM-CP preparation: 5 full exams.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
  • Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
  • Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!
More Disparate treatment questions
12 questions (total)
Start 12 question test