Back to Performance Management

Paired comparison

5 minutes 5 Questions

Paired comparison is a performance management technique used by SHRM Certified Professionals to evaluate employees by comparing each one directly against every other employee in a group. This method involves listing all employees and systematically pairing them to assess their relative performance. For each pair, the evaluator determines which employee performs better based on predefined criteria such as job competencies, achievements, and behavior. The results of these comparisons are then tallied to rank employees according to their overall performance. The paired comparison method offers several advantages in performance management. It simplifies the decision-making process by breaking down complex evaluations into a series of direct comparisons, making it easier to discern top performers and identify areas where employees may need improvement. This approach also minimizes biases that can occur in broader rating systems, as each comparison is focused on specific, observable behaviors and outcomes. However, paired comparison has its limitations. It can be time-consuming, especially with larger teams, as the number of comparisons increases exponentially with the number of employees. Additionally, it may not account for the varying roles and responsibilities of different employees, potentially leading to unfair assessments if not carefully managed. To mitigate these challenges, SHRM Certified Professionals often supplement paired comparisons with other evaluation methods, such as self-assessments or 360-degree feedback, to provide a more comprehensive view of employee performance. In the context of SHRM certification, mastering paired comparison techniques enables HR professionals to implement fair and effective performance management systems. By accurately ranking employees, organizations can make informed decisions regarding promotions, training needs, and performance improvement plans. Ultimately, paired comparison helps create a transparent and objective performance evaluation process that aligns with organizational goals and fosters a culture of continuous improvement.

Comprehensive Guide to Paired Comparison in Performance Management

Introduction

Paired comparison is a fundamental technique in performance management that facilitates objective decision-making by comparing entities in pairs. This guide explores its importance, functionality, and strategies for tackling related exam questions.

Why Paired Comparison is Important
Paired comparison helps organizations systematically evaluate and prioritize employees, projects, or processes. By breaking down complex decisions into manageable pairwise evaluations, it minimizes bias and enhances the accuracy of performance assessments.

What is Paired Comparison?
Paired comparison is a method where items are compared in pairs to judge which of each pair is preferred or has a higher value. In performance management, it typically involves comparing employees' performances two at a time to rank them.

How Paired Comparison Works
1. **Identify Criteria**: Determine the performance criteria relevant to the evaluation.
2. **List Entities**: List all employees or items to be compared.
3. **Compare in Pairs**: Evaluate each pair based on the criteria.
4. **Assign Scores**: Assign scores or preferences for each comparison.
5. **Aggregate Results**: Sum the scores to rank the entities.

Answering Exam Questions on Paired Comparison
When faced with exam questions on paired comparison, it's essential to understand the underlying principles and steps involved. Questions may ask you to perform a paired comparison analysis, interpret results, or explain its advantages and limitations.

Exam Tips: Answering Questions on Paired Comparison

  • Understand the Process: Be clear on each step of the paired comparison method.
  • Practice with Examples: Familiarize yourself with sample questions to build confidence.
  • Show Your Work: When performing calculations, clearly outline each pairwise comparison and scoring.
  • Highlight Key Benefits: Emphasize objectivity and reduction of bias in your explanations.
  • Manage Your Time: Allocate appropriate time to perform comparisons without rushing.

Test mode:
Start practice test
SHRM-CP - Performance Management Example Questions

Test your knowledge of Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3)

Question 1

In the paired comparison method, when comparing multiple HR strategies, what determines the final ranking of each strategy?

Correct Answer: The number of times each strategy is preferred over others in the pairwise comparisons.

In the paired comparison method, each strategy is compared directly against every other strategy in pairs. The final ranking is determined by the number of times each strategy is preferred over the others in these comparisons, reflecting its relative strength or preference among stakeholders. The other options are incorrect because average scores based on stakeholder feedback do not necessarily involve direct pairwise preferences, total implementation cost is unrelated to preference ranking, and the order of introduction does not consider stakeholder preferences.

Question 2

As an HR manager, you're using the paired comparison method to prioritize various employee engagement initiatives. After completing all pairwise evaluations, what is the next step to finalize the ranking of these initiatives?

Correct Answer: Aggregate the number of times each initiative was chosen over others to establish their overall priority.

After conducting all pairwise evaluations, aggregating the number of times each initiative was chosen over others provides a clear basis for establishing their overall priority. This final tally directly reflects the preferences identified during the comparisons. The other options either involve additional steps that are not part of the standard paired comparison process or consider factors irrelevant to the prioritization based solely on pairwise preferences.

Question 3

In the paired comparison method, which mathematical technique is commonly used to derive the final priority weights from the pairwise comparison matrix?

Correct Answer: Eigenvector method

The eigenvector method is the commonly used mathematical technique in the paired comparison method to derive final priority weights from the pairwise comparison matrix. It involves calculating the principal eigenvector of the matrix, which represents the relative weights of the criteria. Other methods like arithmetic mean, simple averaging, and geometric mean are not typically employed for this purpose as they do not capture the hierarchical relationships and dependencies as effectively as the eigenvector method.

Go Premium

SHRM Certified Professional Preparation Package (2024)

  • 4708 Superior-grade SHRM Certified Professional practice questions.
  • Accelerated Mastery: Deep dive into critical topics to fast-track your mastery.
  • Unlock Effortless SHRM-CP preparation: 5 full exams.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: Full refund with no questions if unsatisfied.
  • Bonus: If you upgrade now you get upgraded access to all courses
  • Risk-Free Decision: Start with a 7-day free trial - get premium features at no cost!
More Paired comparison questions
12 questions (total)
Start 12 question test